Guide: Opening vs. Closing Credit Cards: What Helps and What Hurts

Your credit score is an ever-evolving snapshot of your financial habits, and one of the most misunderstood aspects involves opening or closing credit card accounts. Many consumers are surprised to learn that a well-intentioned decision—like closing an unused card or opening a new one for better rewards—can actually hurt their credit score.

This guide unpacks the pros and cons of both actions and explores how each impacts your Middle Credit Score®. By the end, you’ll be equipped with the insights needed to manage your credit cards more strategically and avoid unintentional score setbacks.

Opening a New Credit Card: The Benefits and Risks

Opening a new credit card can be a smart move if done strategically. It’s often recommended for building credit, earning valuable rewards, and increasing your available credit limits—all of which can have long-term benefits. However, new accounts can also introduce short-term disruptions to your credit profile.

Benefits:

• Increased Available Credit: One of the most immediate benefits of opening a new credit card is the increase in your total available credit. If your existing credit cards are carrying balances, this can significantly lower your overall credit utilization ratio—a major factor in credit scoring.
• Improved Credit Mix: Credit scoring models like FICO and VantageScore consider the types of credit you manage (installment loans, revolving credit, etc.). Adding a new credit card can help diversify your credit mix, which accounts for about 10% of your FICO score.
• Access to Rewards and Perks: Many credit cards offer introductory bonuses, cash back, points, or travel rewards. These features can add real value if the card is used responsibly and paid in full each month.
• Building or Rebuilding Credit: For those new to credit or recovering from past credit issues, opening a secured or entry-level credit card can be a crucial first step toward building a stronger credit history.

Risks:

• Hard Inquiry Impact: Every time you apply for a new credit card, a hard inquiry is added to your credit report. While the impact is usually small (a few points), multiple inquiries in a short period can add up and may signal risk to lenders.
• Reduced Average Age of Credit: Adding a new card reduces the average age of your credit accounts. This component of your credit score reflects the length of your credit history. A shorter average can cause a small decline in your score, especially if your credit file is young.
• Potential for Overspending: New credit can be tempting. If you’re not disciplined, having more available credit might encourage you to spend beyond your means.
• Delayed Impact: While the benefits of a new card can be substantial, they are not immediate. Your score might temporarily dip before you see the positive effects.

Strategic Tip: If you’re planning to open a new credit card, avoid doing so within three to six months of applying for a major loan like a mortgage. Lenders view recent credit inquiries as signs of increased credit risk.

Closing a Credit Card: The Unseen Consequences

Closing a credit card may seem like a good idea—especially if it’s one you rarely use or one with an annual fee you no longer want to pay. However, the implications of closing a credit card can be complex and sometimes damaging to your credit profile.

Potential Downsides:

• Higher Credit Utilization: When you close a card, your overall credit limit decreases, which can cause your credit utilization rate to rise—especially if you carry balances on other cards. For example, if you had $10,000 in total credit and $2,000 in balances, your utilization would be 20%. Closing a $2,000-limit card would raise your utilization to 25%, which may negatively impact your score.
• Reduced Credit History: While closed accounts in good standing can stay on your credit report for up to 10 years, they no longer contribute to your active credit history. Over time, as older accounts age off your report, the impact of closing them can become more significant.
• Loss of Positive Payment History: Payment history accounts for 35% of your FICO score. While history remains for a while, closing a card stops new, positive data from being added. Eventually, that good history drops off.
• Diminished Credit Mix: If you don’t have many revolving accounts, closing a card might shrink your overall credit diversity.

When It Makes Sense:

• Annual Fees Are No Longer Worth It: If you’re paying a high annual fee and not using the card’s benefits, it may make sense to cancel it.
• You’ve Consolidated or Transferred Balances: If you’ve paid down your balance and shifted it elsewhere, closing the card might simplify your finances.
• It’s a High-Risk Account: If you’re tempted to overspend or the card’s terms have changed unfavorably, closing it might be the healthier choice.

Pro Tip: Before closing a card, consider asking the issuer to downgrade your account to a no-fee version. This way, you can preserve your credit limit and history while eliminating the cost.

Middle Credit Score® Insight: Timing Is Critical

Lenders—particularly mortgage lenders—use your Middle Credit Score®, which is the median of your three credit bureau scores. Even minor differences between the bureaus can affect this middle score, especially during underwriting for a loan.

Because new accounts and closed accounts may be reported at different times or inconsistently across bureaus, timing is everything. A high utilization on one bureau, a recently opened account on another, or a recently closed card on the third can throw your Middle Credit Score® out of sync.

Why It Matters:

• If your scores are 720, 705, and 680, your Middle Credit Score® is 705.
• If closing a card drops the 705 to 695, your Middle Score becomes 695—potentially affecting your loan rate.

Avoid opening or closing credit accounts within 90–120 days before applying for a major loan. This ensures your credit profile remains stable and predictable during the lender’s review process.

Real-World Scenarios: What Helps and What Hurts

Scenario 1: Closing Your First Credit Card

• Amanda has a 15-year-old credit card with no annual fee. It’s not her primary card anymore, but she wants to close it. Doing so would drop her average credit age significantly.
• Outcome: Her score drops 10–20 points, and she loses valuable payment history over time.
• Better Approach: Keep the card open, use it occasionally for a small bill, and pay it off each month.

Scenario 2: Opening Multiple Cards in One Year

• Jason opens three new cards in nine months to chase sign-up bonuses.
• Outcome: His average age of credit drops, and multiple inquiries lower his score by 20–30 points temporarily.
• Better Approach: Open one card per year at most. Space out applications to allow scores to recover.

Scenario 3: Closing a High-Limit Card with a Balance on Another

• Melissa has two cards: one with a $5,000 limit and a $4,000 balance, and another with a $10,000 limit she rarely uses. She closes the $10,000-limit card.
• Outcome: Her utilization jumps from 26% to 80%, and her score plummets.
• Better Approach: Keep the high-limit card open and active.

Best Practices for Strategic Credit Card Management

• Monitor Your Utilization: Keep your utilization under 30%, ideally under 10%. Spread balances across cards rather than maxing out one.
• Maintain Long-Standing Accounts: Older accounts help your score. Don’t close them unless absolutely necessary.
• Downgrade Before Closing: Ask for a no-fee version of a card before canceling it.
• Use All Cards Occasionally: Even inactive cards should see periodic activity to remain in good standing and prevent involuntary closures.
• Avoid Applying for Credit Before Major Purchases: Hold off on new applications in the months leading up to applying for a mortgage or car loan.
• Check Your Reports Frequently: Ensure all accounts are reporting accurately. Errors can undermine your efforts to manage cards strategically.

Both opening and closing credit cards can help or hurt your score depending on the context and timing. Rather than acting on impulse or misinformation, take a strategic approach that aligns with your long-term financial goals. By understanding the impact on your Middle Credit Score®, you’ll be better positioned to manage your credit profile, qualify for favorable loan terms, and maintain financial flexibility.

Every decision—whether to open a rewards card, close an unused account, or consolidate balances—should be weighed against its potential credit impact. With informed timing, consistent payment behavior, and proper utilization management, your credit cards can become powerful tools in your personal financial strategy.

Middle Credit Score® Support Center
Browse Lenders® – Speak with a Lending Expert