Guide: Tackling Medical Debt— What Credit Models Are Starting to Ignore—and What They Still Count

Medical debt is one of the leading causes of financial distress in the United States—and for many, it arrives without warning. You didn’t take on the debt for a vacation or luxury purchase. You didn’t overspend. You simply got sick or injured, and now you’re left with bills that can stretch into thousands of dollars. Worse, even if the balance is being disputed or was caused by an insurance delay, that debt can still show up on your credit report. For years, medical collections have damaged credit scores across all income levels. But recent changes in how credit scoring models treat medical debt have brought hope to millions. In this guide, we’ll break down those changes—and what medical debt still means for your Middle Credit Score®.

In 2022, the major credit bureaus—Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion—announced sweeping reforms to how they report medical debt. These changes include removing paid medical collections from credit reports, extending the reporting grace period to 12 months after the debt is assigned to collections, and excluding medical debts under $500. These updates reflect a growing recognition that medical debt is not the same as consumer debt. Often involuntary and unpredictable, it doesn’t indicate irresponsible borrowing in the way that credit card delinquency or personal loan defaults might. However, these changes only apply to certain types of debt and not all scoring models have fully adopted them—especially the older versions still used by mortgage lenders.

Understanding which credit models ignore medical debt—and which still factor it in—is critical. For example, FICO 9 and VantageScore 4.0 both reduce the impact of medical debt significantly. But many lenders, particularly those in the mortgage industry, still use FICO 2, 4, or 5, which treat medical collections the same as any other. That means if you’re applying for a mortgage or refinancing, medical debt could still hurt your approval odds or interest rate. We’ll explain how to check which scoring model your lender uses, and how to tailor your debt strategy accordingly. We’ll also explore why it’s so important to keep up with medical bill follow-ups, even when the system feels slow or unfair.

This guide also covers your rights under the No Surprises Act, how to request itemized billing statements, and how to escalate disputes with hospitals, insurance companies, and collection agencies. We’ll help you learn how to verify whether a medical debt was reported in error, what to do if you’ve already paid but it’s still listed on your report, and how to request removal once it’s paid. In some cases, medical providers will allow payment plans with zero interest, and many nonprofit hospitals are legally required to offer financial assistance—but these programs aren’t always promoted. We’ll walk you through how to find them and how to qualify.

Ultimately, the goal is to shield your Middle Credit Score® from avoidable damage while resolving your medical debt in a way that keeps you financially stable. Whether you’re dealing with $300 or $30,000, the principles are the same: understand your rights, stay organized, and negotiate or challenge the debt before it becomes a barrier to credit opportunities. In a system that often feels rigged against patients, this guide will help you take back control—both financially and emotionally—so you can focus on healing, not just paying bills.

Tactical Breakdown

🧭 Step 1: Know What’s Changed in Medical Debt Reporting

Recent changes from the three major credit bureaus—Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion—have significantly shifted how medical debt is reported:

📌 These reforms offer major score protection—but only if the debt is classified correctly and resolved within the grace period.

🧾 Step 2: Review Your Credit Reports for Medical Debt Entries

Start by requesting your free credit reports from all three bureaus via AnnualCreditReport.com.

Create a table like this to track:

📌 Use this audit to identify which debts are eligible for removal, which still impact your Middle Credit Score®, and which may be reported in error.

🧠 Step 3: Understand What Credit Models Still Count Medical Debt

Even with these changes, not all credit scoring models treat medical debt equally:

📉 Step 4: Prevent Medical Debt from Going to Collections

To protect your score, use this checklist after receiving a medical bill:

✅ Ask for an itemized statement
✅ Confirm what insurance has and has not covered
✅ Dispute any errors with your provider and insurance company
✅ Set up a payment plan with the provider
✅ Request financial hardship assistance if eligible
✅ Avoid using credit cards or personal loans to pay medical bills

📌 Most hospitals and clinics are willing to work with you—especially nonprofits that receive tax benefits for offering charity care.

🛑 Step 5: What to Do If Medical Debt Hits Collections

If a medical collection shows up on your credit report, take immediate steps:

1. Validate the debt under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA)
2. Dispute any inaccuracies with the credit bureau
3. Negotiate directly with the provider, not just the collection agency
4. Pay and request deletion if eligible (ask for a “pay for delete” in writing)
5. Follow up after 30–60 days to ensure removal if the debt was under $500 or paid in full

📌 Paid medical debts should be automatically removed, but it’s still your responsibility to verify this happened.

💬 Step 6: Scripts for Disputes and Negotiations

Dispute Letter Template (for credit bureau):

Dear [Bureau Name],

I am writing to dispute the following medical debt listed on my credit report:

Account Name: [Collection Agency]
Account Number: [XXXXXXX]
Amount: [$XXX]

I believe this debt is inaccurate due to [reason: already paid, under $500, not mine, etc.]. Please investigate and remove this item.

Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Address]
[DOB and last 4 of SSN]

Settlement Offer Script (to collection agency):

“I’m calling about an outstanding medical debt listed on my report. I’d like to resolve this today in exchange for deletion of the account. If I pay [amount], will you agree in writing to delete the item from all three bureaus?”

💡 Step 7: Use Payment Plans and Medical Credit with Caution

Many hospitals offer zero-interest payment plans—this is ideal.

Avoid these high-risk options:

📌 Only use financing if it’s interest-free, short-term, and won’t interfere with other credit goals.

📊 Step 8: Monitor Your Score and Prepare for Mortgage Readiness

Use Middle Credit Score® tracking tools to monitor progress after paying or removing medical debt. Focus on:

• Maintaining 100% payment history
• Keeping utilization below 30%
• Reducing number of accounts with balances
• Avoiding new hard inquiries

If applying for a mortgage in 6–12 months:

• Aim to resolve or remove medical debts immediately
• Get letters confirming paid status or deletion
• Provide documentation during underwriting if accounts still appear

📌 Mortgage lenders often manually review collections—having proof of resolution helps your approval odds.

🧰 Step 9: Tools & Resources

• AnnualCreditReport.com – Free access to your reports
• CFPB Dispute Portal – File disputes and complaints
• IRS Form 982 – May exempt forgiven debt from taxes if insolvent
• Hospital Financial Assistance Forms – Often available online
• MiddleCreditScore.com Planner – Tracks medical debt recovery and future score goals

✅ Final Summary: Take Control Before Collections Take Over

✔ Always check your medical bills—don’t assume accuracy
✔ Act quickly to set up payment or negotiate before collections
✔ Know your rights and the credit scoring model your lender will use
✔ Avoid unnecessary loans or credit cards to pay medical bills
✔ Monitor and verify that resolved medical debts are removed from your reports

Medical debt doesn’t have to ruin your credit or your confidence. Use these strategies to protect your score, advocate for yourself, and move forward with financial clarity—especially if homeownership or loan approvals are on the horizon.

Middle Credit Score® Support Center
Browse Lenders® – Speak with a Lending Expert