Case Study: From Default to Approval—How Disputing Errors Saved a Home Purchase

When a critical error appeared on David and Sarah’s credit report, their mortgage approval was immediately halted. A defaulted student loan that did not belong to them was reported, tanking their Middle Credit Score® by nearly 75 points. Facing the possibility of losing their dream home, they took immediate action to dispute the error and restore their credit. This case study details their journey from default to approval and the strategic steps they took to protect their financial future.

Step 1: Discovering the Error

David and Sarah first learned about the error during the underwriting phase of their mortgage application. The lender flagged a defaulted student loan that neither of them recognized. They immediately:

• Requested Full Credit Reports: Pulled their reports from Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion.
• Identified the Error: The defaulted loan appeared on all three reports under Sarah’s Social Security Number but was linked to a different middle initial and address.
• Documented the Mistake: They saved PDFs of each report and highlighted the discrepancies.

Pro Tip:

• Always check the spelling of your name, Social Security Number, and address for errors.
• Scrutinize every account for inaccuracies, including balances and payment status.

Advanced Techniques:

• Fraud Alert Placement: They placed fraud alerts on their credit files to prevent further damage.
• Credit Monitoring Activation: Signed up for real-time alerts to track any changes during the dispute.
• Credit Freeze: Placed a freeze on their credit to prevent unauthorized access during the dispute process.
• Early Warning System: Set up email and text alerts for any changes or inquiries on their reports.

Step 2: Gathering Documentation

To build a strong case, David and Sarah collected:

• Proof of Identity: Copies of their driver’s licenses, Social Security cards, and utility bills.
• Proof of Non-Ownership: Signed affidavits stating they never took out the loan.
• Dispute Letters: Drafted letters for each credit bureau explaining the error in detail.
• Bank Statements: Provided transaction history to show no payments or interactions with the loan servicer.
• Notarized Affidavit of Non-Ownership: This document was sent alongside their dispute for added credibility.
• Request for Debt Validation: A certified letter sent to the servicer demanding verification of the debt’s validity.

Pro Tip:

• Attach a copy of the credit report with the error highlighted for clarity.

Advanced Techniques:

• Certified Mail with Return Receipt: Ensured proof of delivery and tracking.
• Request for Original Documentation: They demanded the original signed loan agreement that linked Sarah to the debt.
• Method of Verification (MOV) Request: Asked each bureau to provide proof of how the debt was verified.
• Debt Validation Letters: Sent to the student loan servicer to demand verification of the debt’s authenticity.
• Demand for Signature Verification: Requested that the original lender provide a signature verification of the alleged debt agreement.

Step 3: Filing the Disputes

David and Sarah filed disputes with all three credit bureaus:

• Online Dispute Submission: For immediate acknowledgment of their claim.
• Certified Mail Follow-Up: Sent hard copies of their dispute letters and documentation to each bureau.
• Contact with the Loan Servicer: Reached out directly to the student loan servicer to inform them of the error.
• Dispute with the Original Creditor: Contacted the original lender to verify the debt’s authenticity and challenge its reporting.

Pro Tip:

• Use direct language in your disputes—state the error and demand correction.
• Always include account numbers and specific details to avoid confusion.

Advanced Techniques:

• CFPB Complaint Filing: Filed a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to escalate the matter.
• Method of Verification Request: Asked each bureau to provide proof of how the debt was validated.
• Escalation to Supervisors: If no response was received within 30 days, the case was escalated.
• Cease and Desist Communication: Sent to the loan servicer to halt collection activities during the investigation.
• Demand for Loan History: Requested a full transaction history of the alleged debt to check for discrepancies.

Step 4: Following Up Persistently

David and Sarah:

• Called Weekly: Kept regular contact with credit bureaus to track progress.
• Documented Every Call: Maintained a log of conversations, dates, and contact names.
• Requested Updates in Writing: Ensured all communications were verified by email or letter.
• Demanded MOV Documentation: Repeatedly requested the Method of Verification to understand how the debt was verified.

Pro Tip:

• Persistence is key. Credit bureaus are required to respond within 30 days of a dispute.
• Keep all responses organized in a binder or digital folder.

Advanced Techniques:

• State Attorney General Notification: Alerted the AG’s office to put pressure on the servicer.
• Request for Reinvestigation: If the dispute was not resolved, they demanded a reinvestigation.
• CFPB Follow-Up Complaint: Filed a second complaint when the bureau did not comply within the mandated timeframe.
• Pressing for Early Exclusion: Requested early exclusion of the erroneous loan under FCRA guidelines.
• Third-Party Verification: Demanded that third-party collections provide signed documentation of debt ownership.

Step 5: Resolution and Mortgage Approval

Within 45 days:

• Loan Removed: All three bureaus deleted the student loan from their credit reports.
• Credit Scores Restored: Their Middle Credit Score® bounced back, allowing their mortgage approval to proceed.
• Final Verification: David and Sarah pulled fresh reports to confirm the removal.
• Rebuild Strategy: Enrolled in Experian Boost® and opened a secured credit card to further elevate their scores.

Pro Tip:

• Always pull updated reports after disputes are resolved to confirm changes.

Advanced Techniques:

• Credit Monitoring Services: They signed up for continuous monitoring to catch future errors early.
• Fraud Alert Extensions: Extended their fraud alerts to prevent reoccurrence.
• Credit Lock Services: Added an extra layer of security to prevent unauthorized changes.
• Monthly Credit Report Checks: Set reminders to pull their credit report every 60 days for one year.
• Ongoing Debt Verification Requests: Scheduled annual verification requests to ensure no false debts appear.

David and Sarah’s journey illustrates how quick action and strategic dispute processes can reverse major errors and protect financial goals. Their persistence, documentation, and understanding of their rights under the FCRA saved their home purchase and restored their credit. Their experience is a blueprint for others facing sudden credit challenges during major financial milestones.

Middle Credit Score® Support Center
Browse Lenders® – Speak with a Lending Expert