Case Study: Fraudulent Loans in My Name—A Real Recovery Story

Identity theft can take many forms, but few are more damaging than fraudulent loans. Unlike unauthorized credit card charges that can often be caught quickly and disputed with relative ease, fraudulent loans—such as personal loans, auto loans, or payday advances—can sit unnoticed on a credit report for weeks or even months. And once they do appear, the process of disputing them is far more complex. The financial consequences are long-term, and the emotional toll can be overwhelming.

This case study follows the journey of Jamal, a 35-year-old professional who discovered multiple fraudulent loans in his name totaling over $22,000. These loans had been approved using his Social Security number and outdated personal information that was likely accessed from a data breach years earlier. By the time Jamal realized what had happened, one of the loans was already delinquent, and a second had been sent to collections. His Middle Credit Score®—which had been 721—plummeted to 598 within 45 days.

This introduction will provide the full background on how Jamal became a victim, what his immediate responses were, and why this case provides important lessons for anyone concerned about the accuracy of their credit profile. We’ll also explore how the ripple effects of identity theft—particularly when it involves fraudulent loans—can impact every facet of a borrower’s financial life, from mortgage qualification and auto loan rates to employment background checks and insurance premiums.

Jamal’s story is unique, but the process he followed to recover can apply to thousands of others. His case illustrates:

• How to recognize the subtle signs of fraudulent loans
• Which rights under the FCRA and FTC identity theft laws provided the most support
• How to strategically rebuild a damaged Middle Credit Score® using credit tools and legal protections
• Why persistence and organization are key to getting full resolution across all three credit bureaus

Most importantly, this case study shows that recovery is possible—and even likely—when borrowers understand the process, know their rights, and commit to a long-term credit recovery plan.

In the pages that follow, we’ll break down each step Jamal took—from the first alert on his credit report, through the filing of police and FTC reports, to the multi-month dispute process and final recovery of his credit standing. This introduction sets the stage for a powerful journey of resilience, legal empowerment, and score restoration.

Let’s begin with Jamal’s moment of discovery, and the shocking realization that his identity had been used to take out loans he never authorized.

Month-by-Month Breakdown: Jamal’s Recovery Timeline

Month 1: Discovery and Shock

• Jamal receives an alert from his credit monitoring service about a new account.
• Logs in to find two personal loans—one newly opened, one already 30 days past due.
• Pulls all three credit reports and confirms both loans appear on Equifax and Experian, but only one is on TransUnion.
• Notices a hard inquiry from a payday lender he never contacted.
• Middle Credit Score® drops from 721 to 598.
• Files an FTC Identity Theft Report through IdentityTheft.gov.
• Visits the local police department and files an official police report.

Month 2: Lockdown and Disputes Begin

• Places a fraud alert on his credit file with Equifax, which notifies the other two bureaus.
• Initiates a credit freeze on all three bureaus to prevent further damage.
• Sends certified mail disputes to Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion, including:
  • FTC Identity Theft Report
  • Police report
  • Proof of identity and address
  • Highlighted credit reports
• Sends dispute letters directly to the payday lenders involved.
• Receives responses acknowledging investigations underway.

Month 3: Verifications and Pushback

• Equifax removes one account temporarily pending further investigation.
• Experian claims insufficient evidence and asks for more documentation.
• Jamal responds with additional documentation, including notarized affidavit of fraud.
• Contacts the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) to file a complaint against one lender.
• Sends follow-up letter to TransUnion demanding removal under FCRA Section 605B.
• Middle score rises slightly to 614 as one account is marked “in dispute.”

Month 4: First Removals and Recovery Steps

• Equifax confirms one loan has been deleted.
• Experian updates account status to “fraudulent, under investigation.”
• Jamal opens a secured credit card with a $300 deposit.
• Makes small purchases and pays balance in full before statement date.
• Signs up for credit builder loan through a fintech platform.
• Updates credit monitoring preferences to receive weekly score alerts.

Month 5: Additional Success and New Tradelines

• Experian deletes both fraudulent loans.
• TransUnion deletes the one loan showing on their report.
• Jamal is added as an authorized user on a family member’s credit card.
• Secured card posts 30 days of positive payment history.
• Credit builder loan posts as a new installment account.
• Middle score jumps to 648.

Month 6: Dispute Closure and Monitoring Routine

• All bureaus now reflect accurate information.
• Jamal sets reminders to check his credit monthly and pull full reports quarterly.
• Establishes a fraud recovery binder to organize:
  • Copies of all disputes
  • Bureau responses
  • Timeline logs
  • Monthly credit scores
• Submits written confirmation of account resolution to the CFPB to close complaint.
• Freezes remain in place.

Month 7–8: Stabilization Phase

• Continues usage of secured credit card (5–7% utilization).
• Pays credit builder loan on time.
• No new inquiries or negative items.
• Experian score reaches 678, TransUnion 672, Equifax 669.
• Middle Credit Score® now 672.

Month 9–10: Confidence Returns

• Secured credit card issuer offers graduation to unsecured card—Jamal accepts.
• Credit limit raised from $300 to $1000.
• Applies for a second card with his credit union—approved for $1500 limit.
• Starts small automatic subscription payments to maintain history.
• Monthly monitoring reveals a 687 middle score.

Month 11–12: Full Circle

• CFPB confirms all disputes resolved.
• Jamal removes fraud alerts but keeps freezes in place.
• Reviews full credit reports for the year—no remaining signs of fraud.
• Middle Credit Score® reaches 713.
• Applies for a mortgage pre-approval and qualifies with favorable terms.

Jamal’s case shows the power of organized, persistent credit recovery. By understanding his rights, documenting every step, and layering in positive tradelines, he reclaimed his credit profile—and his financial peace of mind.

Middle Credit Score® Support Center
Browse Lenders® – Speak with a Lending Expert