Case Study: Erasing Mistakes—How One Family Removed False Collections in 60 Days

When erroneous collections appeared on the credit report of the Johnson family, their Middle Credit Score® dropped significantly, affecting their ability to secure financing for a new home. With determination, strategic dispute methods, and proper understanding of their rights under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), they successfully removed these false collections in just 60 days. This case study outlines their step-by-step process and provides insights for others facing similar challenges.

Step 1: Identifying the Error

The Johnson family first discovered the error during a routine credit check while preparing for a mortgage application. Two collections accounts, which they did not recognize, appeared on their credit report from Equifax and TransUnion. They immediately:

• Verified the Debts: Checked the account numbers, amounts, and dates against their records.
• Pulled All Three Credit Reports: They found the accounts listed on Equifax and TransUnion but not Experian, indicating reporting inconsistencies.
• Documented the Errors: They saved screenshots and downloaded PDF copies of their credit reports as proof.

Pro Tip:

• Always pull credit reports from all three bureaus; errors can appear on one and not the others.
• Cross-check your personal information (name, address, Social Security Number) to spot inaccuracies that may cause mistaken identity.

Advanced Techniques:

• Credit Monitoring Services: The Johnsons signed up for real-time credit monitoring, allowing them to catch discrepancies early.
• Annual Checkups: They committed to pulling their reports every four months (one bureau at a time) for ongoing monitoring.
• Trigger Alerts for Changes: Activated alert systems for any changes in their credit reports to catch discrepancies immediately.

Step 2: Assembling Documentation

To strengthen their dispute, the Johnsons gathered:

• Proof of Payments: Bank statements showing no payments to the listed accounts.
• Identity Verification: Copies of their driver’s licenses and utility bills to confirm their identity.
• Account Statements: Documents from legitimate creditors showing account status.
• Dispute Letters: They drafted detailed dispute letters for each bureau explaining the error.
• Sworn Affidavit of Non-Ownership: A notarized statement asserting they did not own the debt.
• Certified Debt Validation Request: A formal request for proof of debt ownership from the collector.

Advanced Techniques:

• Certified Mail with Return Receipt: Ensures proof of delivery for dispute letters.
• Method of Verification (MOV) Request: Included in their letter to demand proof of how the debts were verified.
• Notarized Statements: Added legal weight to their disputes by including notarized affidavits.
• Request for Original Contract: Demanded original documentation that showed they consented to the debt.

Step 3: Filing the Disputes

The Johnsons filed disputes with Equifax and TransUnion using:

• Online Dispute Portals: They submitted digital copies of their documentation directly.
• Certified Mail Follow-Up: Mailed hard copies to ensure proper handling.
• Direct Creditor Contact: Reached out to the collection agencies listed to verify the debts directly.
• CFPB Complaint Filing: Submitted a complaint to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau for added pressure.

Pro Tip:

• Always dispute with both the credit bureau and the collection agency for maximum impact.
• Request a Method of Verification to understand how the debt was validated.

Advanced Techniques:

• Multiple Points of Contact: The Johnsons contacted both the original creditor and the collection agency for verification.
• Demand for Documentation: They insisted on receiving the original signed contract that created the debt.
• Third-Party Debt Validation: Requested a copy of the bill of sale if the debt was transferred to a third-party collector.
• Cease and Desist Letters: Sent cease-and-desist communication to collection agencies to halt harassment during validation.

Step 4: Following Up Consistently

After submitting their disputes:

• Weekly Follow-Ups: The Johnsons called the credit bureaus for status updates.
• Request for Status Updates: Submitted written requests for updates if no response was received within 30 days.
• Escalation to Supervisors: If calls did not provide clarity, they requested escalation.

Pro Tip:

• Keep a detailed call log with dates, names, and notes for every interaction.
• Insist on written confirmations of conversations and decisions.

Advanced Techniques:

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) Complaint: Filed a complaint when no update was provided after 30 days.
• State Attorney General Notification: Alerted their state’s AG office about potential reporting violations.
• Request for Reinvestigation: If the dispute was not resolved satisfactorily, the Johnsons requested a reinvestigation under FCRA guidelines.
• CFPB Follow-Up: If the dispute lingered beyond 30 days, they filed a second-level complaint for lack of compliance.

Step 5: Resolution and Credit Report Updates

Within 60 days:

• Collections Removed: Both Equifax and TransUnion confirmed that the collections were deleted.
• Credit Scores Restored: Their Middle Credit Score® rebounded, allowing them to proceed with their mortgage application.
• Final Verification: The Johnsons pulled fresh reports from all three bureaus to confirm full removal.
• Rebuild Strategy: They opened a secured credit card and enrolled in Experian Boost® to further elevate their scores.

Pro Tip:

• Always pull updated reports to confirm that deletions are applied across all credit bureaus.
• Set credit monitoring alerts to catch any unexpected changes in real-time.

Advanced Techniques:

• Credit Report Freezes: To prevent further false entries, the Johnsons placed a temporary freeze on all three reports.
• Fraud Alerts: Enabled fraud alerts to receive instant notifications of credit inquiries.
• Monitoring for Re-insertion: They checked monthly for six months to ensure the collections were not reinserted.
• Credit Lock Services: Locked their reports using services like Credit Lock™ to avoid unauthorized changes.

The Johnson family’s experience showcases the importance of diligence and understanding your rights under the FCRA. With proper documentation, strategic disputes, and consistent follow-up, they removed false collections in just 60 days, restoring their Middle Credit Score® and regaining control of their financial future. Their journey is a testament to how informed consumers can effectively challenge inaccurate credit reporting and achieve financial stability.

Middle Credit Score® Support Center
Browse Lenders® – Speak with a Lending Expert